Current Loan
Payments Remaining: --
PMI Payments Remaining: --
Adjusted Balance: --
Escrow +1 mo: --
Escrow Projection: --
Compare Two Refinance Options
No current loan info neededβjust enter the details for the two options you want to compare.
Escrow Details
Enter your full monthly escrow payment if it differs from taxes + insurance.
Break-Even Calculator
Enter your closing costs to calculate the rate needed to break even.
Rounded up to nearest $10
Auto-calculated from itemized costs below, or enter your own value
Itemized Costs/Fees
Enter as positive (will be subtracted)
New Loan
Extra principal payment made with your first payment
Compare Two Refinance Options
Enter the details from two loan scenarios to see them side by side.
A Option A
Required if PMI is entered
Use negative for cash back at closing
B Option B
Required if PMI is entered
Use negative for cash back at closing
Prepared for
Comparative Analysis
Net Position Breakdown at 60 payments
60
| Metric | A Option A | B Option B | Difference |
|---|
Compare to Current Loan
Run a full analysis comparing one of these options against your current loan.
Prepared for
Analysis Summary
Please wait while we crunch the numbers.
This tool provides illustrative comparisons based on your inputs. Results are estimates only and do not represent loan offers or financial advice. Estimated savings assume all inputs, rates, and payment behavior remain unchanged.
(Same Payment)
What if you kept making your current payment on the new loan? Applies monthly savings as extra principal.
Same payment comparison
(Same Remaining Term)
What if both loans paid off at the same time? Increases new payment to match old loan's term.
Same payoff date comparison
What Changed?
Side-by-side comparison of your current vs. new loan
Loan Comparison
Savings Over Time
Explore how your net position changes over the life of the loan
Net Position Breakdown
Payment difference applied as extra principal to equalize payments
Run the analysis to see detailed cost breakdown.
Net Position Analysis
Net Position β Your total financial advantage (or disadvantage) from refinancing at any point in time. Calculated as: Transition Benefits/Costs + Payment Differential + Balance Differential.
Transition Benefits/Costs β The one-time financial impacts at closing: Cash to Close or Cash Back, Escrow Balancing, and Skipped Payments. A positive number means you come out ahead at closing.
Payment Differential β The cumulative difference in payments made. If you've paid less on the new loan than you would have on the old loan, this is positive.
Balance Differential β The difference in remaining balances (Current Balance β New Balance). If the new loan has a lower balance, this is positive because you owe less.
Key Milestones
Break-Even β The payment number when your Net Position first reaches zero. Before this point, you're still "in the red" from refinancing costs.
5-Year Savings β Your net position after 60 payments (5 years). This is a practical milestone that shows whether your refinance is paying off within a typical ownership timeframe. Tap this card to explore how your savings change over time.
Potential Savings β Shows your best potential lifetime savings across three approaches: Apples-to-Apples (equalize payments), Oranges-to-Oranges (equalize payoff dates), and Standard (no extra payments). Tap to compare all three options.
Monthly Metrics
Monthly Savings β The difference between your old total payment (P&I + PMI) and your new total payment. Shown in standard mode when the new payment is lower.
Payments Saved β In Apples-to-Apples mode, the number of payments eliminated by applying your monthly savings as extra principal. If your new payment is higher, this shows how many fewer payments you'd make by paying that higher amount on both loans.
Closing & Escrow
Cash to Close / Cash Back β The total amount shown on your Closing Disclosure. "Cash to Close" means you're bringing money to closing (a cost); "Cash Back" means you're receiving money at closing (a benefit, typically from a cash-out refinance).
Principal Reduction β An optional one-time extra principal payment made with your first payment, typically funded by cash back from the refinance. This reduces your loan balance immediately rather than giving you cash at closing.
Escrow Funding β The initial deposit into your new escrow account, calculated from a 14-month projection to ensure adequate funds for upcoming tax and insurance payments plus the required cushion.
Escrow Balancing β How your old escrow balance impacts the refinance. Shows as "Shortage Financed" (benefit: shortage rolled into loan), "Escrow Refund" (benefit: you get your balance back), or "Overage Applied" (cost: overage reduces payoff but you don't get cash).
Skipped Payments β The mortgage payments you skip between your last old loan payment and your first new loan payment. This cash stays in your pocket and counts as a benefit.
Loan Terms
P&I β Principal & Interest. The base mortgage payment that goes toward your loan balance and interest charges.
PMI β Private Mortgage Insurance. Required when equity is below 20%, typically drops off automatically when the balance reaches 78% of the original purchase price (old loan) or current appraised value (new loan).
Comparison Modes
Apples-to-Apples (A2A) β Equalizes monthly payments between both loan scenarios. If the new payment is lower, the savings go to extra principal on the new loan. If the new payment is higher, that higher amount is paid on both loans, with the difference going to extra principal on the old loan.
Oranges-to-Oranges (O2O) β Equalizes payoff dates by calculating the extra principal needed on the new loan to pay it off when your old loan would have ended. Shows the true monthly cost difference when both loans retire at the same time.
* Estimate Assumptions
This analysis assumes a credit score of --- and an estimated home value of ---. This illustration is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer or commitment to lend. Actual rates, terms, and eligibility are subject to credit approval and may vary based on your complete financial profile.
Break-Even Rate Analysis
Adjust the slider to see the rate needed to recover your costs
Calculation Summary
How this works:
We calculate your current monthly cost (interest + PMI) and determine how much you need to save each month to recover your loan costs. PMI is treated as "effective interest" so the break-even rate accounts for any PMI changes between your old and new loans.
The displayed rate is the base interest rate needed β PMI savings/costs are already factored in.
This is a simplified break-even analysis. For a comprehensive analysis including escrow, PMI tracking, and payment comparisons, select Advanced Mode from the start.